Case Study: The True Cost of Timesheet Fraud

Understand the true cost of timesheet fraud and what it means for your organization

Timework Overview

Timesheet fraud remains a costly and pervasive issue across industries. According to recent research, U.S. businesses lose billions of dollars annually due to fraudulent time reporting. This case study outlines the seven most common types of timesheet fraud, with a focus on data, real-world implications, and prevention strategies.

The True Cost of Timesheet Fraud in the Workplace

1. Inflation of Work Hours

Definition: Employees overreport time worked to appear more productive or to cover up lateness.

Tactics:

  • Logging earlier clock-ins or later clock-outs than actual
  • Inflating break durations or omitting time away from work

Prevalence: Most common type across all industries

Risk Factors: Manual timesheets, lack of real-time tracking

2. Buddy Punching

Definition: One employee clocks in or out for another who is late or absent.

Industry Impact:

  • $373 million/year in estimated losses for U.S. employers
  • 16% of hourly workers admit to participating in buddy punching

Detection Difficulty: High, especially without biometric systems

3. Unauthorized Breaks & Extended Time Off

Definition: Employees take longer or additional breaks than allowed, or misuse sick/vacation time.

Effects:

  • Reduced productivity
  • Payment for non-worked hours
  • Morale issues among compliant employees

4. Overtime Abuse

Definition: Logging regular time as overtime, or working unauthorized extra hours.

Red Flags:

  • Sudden spikes in overtime reports
  • Lack of pre-approval or supporting documentation

Cost Multiplier: Overtime often pays 1.5x or more, increasing the financial impact

5. Ghost Employees

Definition: Wages paid to nonexistent or terminated employees.

Execution:

  • Created by rogue insiders using falsified records
  • Often undetected in large organizations with loose payroll controls

Potential Loss: Thousands per month, especially in long-term fraud

6. Fraudulent Data Entry

Definition: Incorrect or exaggerated hours added during manual or delayed timesheet entry.

Key Issues:

  • Lack of timestamped verification
  • Supervisors approving entries without audits

Risk Period: Times of system outages or retroactive entry permissions

7. Favoritism Fraud

Definition: Supervisors manipulate task assignments or approvals to benefit certain employees.

Forms:

  • Higher pay for favored employees without justification
  • Ignoring inflated timesheets or abuse of overtime

Organizational Cost:

  • Unjustified payroll increases
  • Teamwide resentment and turnover risk

Timework Conclusion & Recommendations

Estimated U.S. Losses from Time Theft: $11 billion+ annually

Top At-Risk Sectors: Retail, construction, public safety, healthcare, Public Sector

Prevention Strategies:

  • Implement a Workforce Management Solution -- Attendance, Time, Scheduling
  • Biometric time clocks or app-based geofencing
  • Real-time tracking dashboards and reports
  • Supervisor audit logs and automatic discrepancy alerts
  • Employee training and anonymous fraud reporting systems

Want to eliminate time fraud risk in your organization?

Timework offers secure, scalable time tracking solutions that prevent fraud, automate reporting, and increase visibility for HR and finance leaders. Reach out to Timework today.

Additional Case Studies

Unlock the Potential
of Your WFM Program

Discover the Timework difference & drive workforce ROI
Let's Talk